Madden 2003 vs. NFL 2K3 @ Gamespot

[Supersonic]

Sind die Xbox Scores, die anderen werde ich noch nachreichen.

Madden NFL 2003 Review

Fazit:

Madden NFL 2003's abundance of modes and the amount of detail in them are sure to keep you busy for quite some time. But the few minor issues in the gameplay and the fact that it has the same general look as last year's game really prevent it from taking the crown in this year's football race, though it's still certainly one of the best football games out there.

Gameplay: 8
Graphics: 8
Sound: 9
Value: 9
Tilt:9
Overall: 8.6 (great)


Sega Sports NFL 2K3 Review

Fazit:

There's very little, if anything, to really complain about in NFL 2K3. The graphics look great, the commentary is interesting and sounds natural, and, most importantly, the game features balanced offensive and defensive gameplay that does an excellent job of mimicking the nuances of the actual sport. In addition, the ESPN license has gone a long way toward giving the game some personality. You'll be treated to the ESPN-style presentation, complete with split-screen replays and music from ESPN programming, which simply tops off an incredible game that any football fan would do well to buy.

Gameplay: 9
Graphics: 9
Sound: 10
Value: 9
Tilt: 9
Overall: 9.1 (superb)


EA ist jetzt ab sofort Segas Bitch.

 

[Supersonic]

So jetzt die PS2 Wertungen:

NFL 2K3

The PlayStation 2 version of Madden NFL 2003 isn't quite as clean as its Xbox counterpart, but otherwise the two versions look identical.
[...]
Madden 2003 for the PlayStation 2 has online play, a robust franchise mode, and plenty of secondary modes to keep you busy, but the minor issues with the running and passing game really prevent it from being the absolute best representation of professional football that's available. Fans of previous Madden games will definitely enjoy it, and any other football fans should certainly give it a look.

Gameplay: 8
Graphics: 8
Sound: 9
Value: 10
Tilt: 10
Overall: 9.0 (superb)

NFL 2K3

In terms of graphics, the PlayStation 2 version of NFL 2K3 seems to be on par with the Xbox version, though it doesn't appear to have the special effects that the Xbox version has.
[...]
With its in-depth franchise mode, online play, excellent running and passing gameplay, and detailed graphics, NFL 2K3 is one of the best football games to date. If you're a fan of NFL football, then you owe it to yourself to pick up NFL 2K3 for the PlayStation 2.

Gameplay: 9
Graphics: 9
Sound: 10
Value: 10
Tilt: 10
Overall: 9.6 (superb)

Fragt mich nicht warum die PS2 Spiele besser bewertet wurden, entweder Fanboy Bonus oder das (noch) nicht funktionierende Online Play der Xbox Versionen... (wobei ich da +0,5 zu viel finde)

Die Gamecube Wertungen entsprechen den Xbox Wertungen.

Sega Sports 0wnz

 

[HoopHero]

Juhuu !!! :anim: